Case study: a District Magistrate, illegal immigrants caught in a flood, and looting reported
Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025
The current sensitivities of illegal immigration into india from Myanmar (Chakmas, Rohingyas) and from Bangladesh have raised several dilemmas. The present case study reflects the same.
Ethical Issues
1. fiscal prudence (in granting relief only to citizens) v/s ethical prudence (towards relief to illegal immigrants) 2. Refugee crisis threatening law and order 3. Bureaucratic attitude (mere rules-based) v/s democratic attitude (discourse ethics) 4. Public safety in question - especially looted households
According to me? - citizens have a claim to common national resources (eg) food packets, rehabilitation, rescue etc.
However, - the claim cannot be ethically speaking "first or priority" in all circumstances. - if life of refugees in question (eg in this case, deadly diseases spreading, they must be protected (Art-21) - humanism [Kant's Categorical Imperative] requires rehab of even illegal immigrants even if temporary. - "Trust but verify" (Russian proverb) - reports of illegal immigrants being behind loots must be verified.
(b) Course of action
1. severity of floods requires urgent rescue and relief - deploy NDRF 2. police patrols against street thugs 3. Inquiry into loots/raids already effected 4. Simultaneously engage with District Disaster management Committee [since I am its chairperson] to raise funds for rehabilitation. 5. Discourse with local MLA on need of rehabilitation of all - using persuasion [Aristotelian triad
- apprising of possible repercussion on relations with neighbour
By adopting aforesaid, I will have upheld principles of "humanitarian ethics" and compassion.