Topper Copies

As the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) provides a judicial mechanism for the peaceful resolution of international disputes. In this context, throw light on the structure and mandate of ICJ. Also, highlight the challenges it faces in fulfilling its mandate.

Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024

Internation Court of Justice is one of six principal organs of United Nations, that promotes global Rule of Law.

Structure of ICJ 1. 15 judges, centred at Hague 2. 9 year team of each judge, selected by UNGA and UNSC individual voting 3. Represent various geographical groups

mandate of ICJ 1. Promote implementation and enforcement of international law codes such as Geneva Convention (against humanitarian crisis) 2. Take cognizance of any case reported by member of UNGA on government of a state (not private individuals) 3. mandate is limited to crimes and not commercial activities such as contract breach (eg- Indus Water Treaty) 4. no suo-Moto cognizance

Challenges associated 1. Lack of enforcement power, in absence of a global prison/police/ investigation force. 2. limited fund availability to maintain own force 3. lack of teeth for any judgement or verdict (eg- recent South Africa case against Israel) 4. overlapping jurisdiction against International criminal court (Rome Statute) 5. lack of global acceptance of verdict in absence of a binding treaty (unlike arbitration)

Potential Solutions 1. UNSC and UNGA to pass a reformative resolution promoting primary punitive powers. 2. Collaboration with Interpol and State governments to promote enforcement. 3. Prevention of continued violations through Sanctions. 4. Independent funding to ensure independence.

ICJ is a central authority to maintain a 'just world order' and needs strengthening.