The Constitution of India provides several rights that empower the individual, yet it balances these freedoms with reasonable restrictions in the larger public interest. Discuss how constitutional restrictions on fundamental rights strike a fine balance between individual interests and societal interests. Also, mention the principles that are considered in evaluating the reasonableness of restrictions with reference case laws.
Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024
Art 19(2) provides for reasonable restrictions on fundamental rights of Art 19 to ensure collective society welfare.
| Empowering Rights | Restrictions | |---|---| | 1. freedom of speech (Art 19(1)(a)) allows speech, thought, expression freedom to citizens. | 1. Against defamation, public morality, foreign affairs, hate speech (Pravasi Bhalai case) etc. | | 2. Freedom of protest and assembly | 2. cannot disrupt public order and law & Impose Sec 144 | | 3. Freedom of Association | 3. Not for unlawful or terroist purposes | | 4. Freedom of Movement in India for unification of India (Ar 19(1)(e)) | 4. not for tribal areas, prostitutes affecting public health, potential hate speech propagators (Mohesh Bhai Tongedia Case) | | 5. Freedom of Residence in any part of country | 5. Except in tribal areas or Scheduled areas (PESA Act, 5th Sched, 6th Sched) | | 6. Freedom of profession or Occupation or trade (19(1)(g)) | 6. Except occupations reserved for state such as Railways, atomic bombs, defence | | 7. Freedom of profession, promotion of Religion (Ar 25) | 7. Except any forceful Conversion and Subject to Ar 21, Ar 14, Ar 19. |
Principles considered in Reasonable Restrictions 1. Principle of proportionality as re-enforced in SBI vs ADR on electoral bonds (Right to Information vs Privacy) 2. Principle of Maximum Action, Least Restriction as proposed in Anuradha Bhasin case. 3. Essential Religious Practices doctrine for restrictions of Religion for secularism 4. Principle of Colourable legislation and Harmonious Construction considered in deciding restrictions. 5. Principle of Pith and Substance.
Hence, Constitution makes a fine balance across diverse groups to reflect socio-cultural realities of India (Ambedkar).