Parliamentary privileges are fundamental for lawmakers to discharge their duties without undue influence. However, ensuring the responsible exercise of these privileges is crucial for fostering public trust and ensuring the accountability of public institutions. Analyse
Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024
Parliamentary privileges refer to the special privileges offered to Parliamentarian to be able to formulate policies and conduct discussions without pressure and with freedom of speech (Art 105).
Discharge duties without influence
| Privilege | Duty | |---|---| | 1. Freedom of speech | 1. Discuss, debate, dissent | | 2. No judicial duty or summon during session | 2. Ensure attendance | | 3. Freedom of publishing | 3. Share information to press for masses | | 4. No special / secret sitting | 4. Promote necessary safety policies / laws. | | 5. Right to remove someone from sitting (by speaker) | 5. Ensure decorum of Parliament. | | 6. Right to not be arrested without speaker knowledge | 6. maintain dignity of Parliament members. |
Responsible exercise crucial
I. for public trust 1. Freedom of speech and vote can't subvert Rule of land (Kerala vs Ajith) 2. Corruption needs to be prevented to maintain trust (eg -> PV Narsimha Rao Case) 3. Ensure fair and honest actions for quality policy making.
II. Accountability 1. no 'cash for Query' and 'Quid Pro Quo' arrangement eg - Mohua Moitra. 2. need to ensure right use of Privileges through Privileges Committee 3. Ensure quality policies to prevent judicial activism and protests (eg - Agriculture Farm laws)
ways to address challenges faced
1. Active Role of Parliamentary Privileges Committee (Justice Verma committee) 2. Judicial Review of any breach of privilege - individual or collective 3. Code of Ethics (IInd ARC) 4. checks and balances through a non-partisan, impartial Speaker.
Privileges enable quality law Making and ensure 'Substantive democracy', but cannot be absolute, but qualified.