The cooperative nature of Indian federalism is being increasingly challenged by emerging differences in Centre-State relations. Discuss. What steps can be taken to strengthen the cooperative spirit of Indian federalism?
Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024
India follows a Quasi-federal structure as provisioned in Articles 245-293 of Constitution.
Cooperative structure of India 1. Administrative → Through centre and state civil servants. 2. Legislative → Through concurrent, state and federal lists (Art 246) 3. Fiscal cooperation : Through Finance Commission (Art 280) and GST (Art 279A) 4. Institutional → Through inter-state water disputes committee (Art 262), inter state council (Art 263) after Sarkaria Commission recommendation. 5. NITI Ayog for cooperative federalism on policy making through collective research and collab
Emerging differences
1. fiscal differences → vertical asymmetry in fund devolution as cess not devolved. (only 41% of tax - NK Singh) 2. Delays in fund devolution for disaster management (eg- SDRF / NDRF) 3. Political parties different in some states and centre → allegations of horizontal asymmetry (eg - Kerala vs UP) 4. Increasing interference of governor through Bill Reservation / delayed assent (Art 200) 5. Centre legislation on state subjects through central sector / sponsored schemes
Steps to strengthen cooperative federalism 1. Clearly demarcated legislation without encroachment on state list (Karnataka vs UoI) 2. Collaborative fund devolution on objective criteria (eg demographic performance reward in south India) 3. Reduction in central sponsored schemes unless necessary (Sarkaria Commission) 4. SR Bommai case laid guidelines for promulgation of President Rule. 5. Increased dissussion, debate, dissent through Rajya Sabha for state representation (Arun Jaitley committee)
Kuldeep Nayar vs UoI have re-iterated the need for federalism as bedrock of the country's growth and democracy.