Topper Copies

"The Basic Structure Doctrine, lauded for safeguarding the core principles of the Constitution against majoritarian impulses, is also criticized for enabling judicial overreach and disturbing the balance of power as envisioned by the Constitution." Elaborate.

Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024

Keshavnanda Bharti case was a Milestone moment in Indian judicial ecosystem, with emergence of Basic Structure Doctrine.

key features of Doctrine (Non exhaustive) 1. Secularism, Democratic, Republic, Sovereign 2. Independence of judiciary 3. Free and fair elections 4. welfare State 5. Bicameralism, federalism.

Lauded for Safeguarding core principles 1. Applied in 99th Amendment (Indian Judicial service) to maintain independence of judiciary → declared null and void 2. Prevents tyranny and despotism of state through Restrictions on amendment (eg - Art 31(c) void by Minerva Mills case) 3. checks and balances on legislative action to protect fundamental Rights (eg - wamnan Rao case) 4. Ensures limited Amendments and 9th Schedule regulation (eg - IR Coelho)

Criticized for judicial overreach

1. Arbitrary structure with no codification of basic structure 2. Violation of distribution of powers through legislative domain work (eg) GRAP set up for pollution On Anoop Baranwal Case on CEC appointment. 3. Secularism vs principled distance often observes over-reach and enthusiasm (eg- Triple Talaq unconstitutional)

Disturbs balance of Power

1. Against Separation of Power doctrine, where legislative action regulated. 2. Legitimization limited due to lack of acceptance and accountability - eg) overturning National capital Delhi administrative service argument. 3. 9th Schedule and Art 368 still allow amendment of constitution, enabled by Basic Structure Doctrine - excessive power to legislature

Hence, Basic Structure Doctrine is a judicial innovation, that has blurred SOP lines in Indian federalism (SC Bar vs UOI) and needs judicial Restraint.