The current composition of the UNSC, with under-representation and un-representation of key regions is detrimental to its legitimacy and effectiveness, underscoring the urgent need for reforms. Elaborate. Also, present a case for India's permanent membership in the UNSC.
Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024
UNSC is one of the six key principal organs of UN to maintain global peace and stability.
current composition - 5 permanent Members (USA, Russia, China, UK, France) - 10 temporary / non-permanent members
Detrimental to legitimacy and effectiveness
I. underRepresentation of global South in permanent members (eg - India, Brazil) & fastest growing countries.
II. Un-Representation of African Union, least developed countries (eg- Tuvalu, guinea, ghena & Rwanda etc).
III. Reduce legitimacy and Effectiveness 1. Inability to Represent the multipolar world order of 21st century 2. Disaccounts unique needs of Global South and developing countries. 3. Considers Terrorism from WWII enemies (eg- Germany, Japan) => not current Reality
Case for India's Membership 1. leader of global South with G77, G20 presidency -> can Represent diverse view point (eg- climate change, agri) 2. G4 membership -> presents non-member Support. 3. QUAD, I2U2, G7 support. 4. 3rd largest economy in PPP terms 5. Accounts for 18% world population.
UNSC Reforms a need of how to ensure "4R - Recognize, Reform, Respect, Review" of multipolar world.