The Speaker's inclination to cater to party loyalties often undermines the dignity and impartiality of the office, eroding public trust in the legislative process. Analyse with the help of recent examples.
Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024
Ar 93 of Constitution provides for a speaker of Lok Sabha, who is the face of independent India (J. Nehru)
loyalty to party undermines dignity and impartiality
1. money Bills (Ar 110) are classified by speaker. However, miss classification questioned (eg - Aadhar) 2. 10th Schedule → Anti defection challenged for not acting in cases of own party [Kihoto Hollohan] 3. Motions of non party / non Minister bills not discussed (only 2/700 bills discussed in 17 LS) 4. Privileges committee often biased against opposition party (eg- Mahua Moitra) 5. 115 MPs suspended from opposition in 17 LS (Dec'23) 6. Jagjit Singh vs Punjab -> partisanship potential and impartiality questionable observed by to Supreme court. 7. Insufficient time to discussions - data: 59% bills passed in 2 weeks
Potential way forward 1. UK Model adoption -> once a speaker always a speaker. 2. Keisham Meghachandra 4 independent tribunal needed for Anti defection. 3. Judicial Review of actions
Nabam Rabia case has highlighted significance of an impartial speaker to maintain "substantive democracy".