Topper Copies

The Indian Constitution does not embody a strict separation of powers rather it introduces a system of checks and balances, with overlapping functions and interdependencies among the legislature, executive, and judiciary. Elaborate.

Mudita Bansal, AIR 44, 2024

Supreme court in Ramkumar Jawaiya case specified that India does not follow a strict separation of Powers

Indian Constitution - a system of checks | balances

1. Judiciary and Executive - Executive can appoint judicial judges (President) as per Third Judge case - Judiciary can maintain executive tyranny by declaring ordinances null and void (Art 13)

2. Judiciary and legislature - Judicial activism through Art 142 to fill any legislative vaccum (eg- Badri Prasad case and live-in legality) - legislature (Parliament) can impeach judicial judges in case of any violation of constitution (both High Court and supreme court judges) - However, independence maintained through Ar 121 (bar on discussing judicial behaviour) and Ar 122 (cannot discuss Parliament proceedings)

3. Executive and legislature - Executive (council of Ministers) responsible to legislature collectively under Ar 75. - legislature constitutes of council of Ministers, who can belong to Lok Sabha or Rajya Sabha. - Executive can advise President to dissolve legislature, while Lok Sabha can pass no confidence motion.

Hence a balanced system of checks, dependence maintained