Topper Copies

How is the 'vertical' and 'horizontal' devolution of taxes to the states decided? Highlighting the concerns raised by some states regarding the devolution of taxes, suggest corrective measures.

Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025

In line with the principle of democratic fiscal devolution, the finance commission was established to devolve the funds from centre to state. (Article 280)

Methodology of Devolution

Central pool of Taxes is distributed amongst states (41 %. according to the recent commission) based on the formula: (vertical)

| Criterion | Weight | |---|---| | Demographic performance | 12.5% | | Population | 15% | | Area of state | 15% | | Income distance | 45% | | Forest and ecology | 10% | | Tax and fiscal effort | 2.5% | | Horizontal/Vertical distribution. | 100% |

Apart from this, specific grants and aids are also provided to states in need. Eg - Special category states. - funds are also allocated via Central sector schemes (60:40 ratio / 90:10)

Concerns raised by states

1. Divergence between income and allocated fund - Eg - Stark difference for Maharashtra and Karnataka - [a bar chart, y-axis "for every ₹1 contributed to central pool", x-axis "In return from devolution": Bihar = 7.2 ₹ (tall bar), Maharashtra 0.8 (short bar)] 2. Delimitation - will further reduce the devolution of Southern states (as reduced population) 3. Punishment for growth → Developed states contribute much more without incentives - Eg - Kerala fund deficit. 4. Growing expenditure of state - Eg Punjab with highest debt. 5. Tied nature of funds in CSS - reduces fiscal innovation. 6. GST cess compensation - delayed and to be removed.

Corrective measures

1. Renew the formula - to incentivise growth in states. 2. Inclusion of states in fiscal commission (A-280) - for greater say in governance. 3. Cap on state revenue expenditure ( to reduce debt / freebies) 4. flexible grants and aids to states in need.

As suggested by 2nd ARC - fiscal devolution must reach upto arteries to prevent high BP at centre.