Topper Copies

"The judiciary has functioned as an institutional corrective, redefining and refining the contours of the Governor's office to prevent its misuse and uphold constitutional principles." Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.

Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025

Judiciary ensures that the scales of constitutional duty and rights are balanced by reforming the constitutional offices like that of governer (A 163 - 167)

Judicial Interventions

1. Setting Timelines: - State of Punjab / Tamil Nadu case: SC has given 1-3 month timeline to act upon the cases and reserve for president. - ∴ Restricted use of A-200. 2. Put under Judicial Review - Rameshwar Prasad case :- governors power and recommendation can be reviewed 3. Curtail A-356 - SR Bommai case : 356 to be used in rare cases with consent of chief Minister. 4. Appointment to be neutral - Nebam Rebia case - Politically neutral background needed to remove conflict of interest 5. Enhance collaboration with Council of Ministers - In the case Samsher Singh vs Union of India - Article 163 - Broadened with aid and advise of Com as compulsory. 6. Floor test - was declared necessary to prove majority in Shivraj Singh vs speaker of MP case

However, this has to be further supplemented with →

- legal changes in Article 200 - Executive and political will - Proactive judicial action against any act against constitution - Public awareness

Judiciary has set a precedent that legislature must follow for ensuring Gandhiji's ideal of Su-raj (Good governance)