The basic structure doctrine acts as a constitutional compass in balancing Parliament's legislative authority and constitutional supremacy. Comment.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
Basic structure doctrine is a Judicial innovation under the Keshavananda Bharti case (1973) which provided a middle path between parliament authority & constitutional supremacy.
Acting as a Balancing compass :-
1. Reduces legislation tyranny & By introducing judicial review. 2. Core ideas of constitions remains [?] and cannot be taken away. - [a circle with a shaded centre, an arrow from the centre to 'core ideas (liberty/equality)' and an arrow from the edge to 'periphery'] 3. Introduces judicial flexibility in interpretation - Pith and substance doctrine over Rule of Law - Substantive justice. - Ex SR Bommai - federalism as Basic structure, cannot repeal any ideal that goes against state interest. 4. Broadens the compatibility b/w legislature and Judiciary. - upholds separation of power with checks + Balances 5. ensures autonomy and accountability . - Ex Recently, co-operative amendment act (97th CAA) Struck down as against federalism . 6. Broadens the scope of fundamental rights and duties. - Ex Article 21 broad interpretation to include privacy.
Way Ahead
As recommended by Justice NV Ramanna ; Basic structure doctrine must be documented to prevent misuse or overweighing of any one side of see-saw.
As B.R. Ambedkar said, constitution is as good as the people who executes them.