Topper Copies

Why are State Legislative Assemblies involved in the election of the President but excluded from the process of impeachment?

Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025

State legislative assemblies (Part VI) of the constitution are an important cog in the Federal wheel of Indian democracy.

SLA's are involved in president election (under article 54) due to :-

1. Federal representation - President of India represents the 'union' ie all of India. 2. Symbolic head - In the westminster model of parliamentary democracy. President is the 'executive head' yet powers remain in hands of PM - All exec Acts taken in name of President - First citizen of India - Republic office open to all - 3. Parliamentary democracy - States have their say in Bills / Acts via → Rajya sabha, → President, → Loksabha } Triple representat^n. 4. Responsibilities related to State - President is crucial in :- 1. Schedule 6/5 area declaration and jurisdiction 2. Imposing state emergencies (A 356)

Hence, states have their say in election process

Excluded from impeachment - Reasons

1. President impeachment is 'Rarest of the rare' case (Never happened in India) 2. State's are represented via Rajya Sabha 3. Involvement would have delayed the impeachment process - making it complex 4. Symbolic head - does not require federal removal.

Yet, President of India continues to represent state interest by acting as a 'guardian of the constitution'