You are posted as the Joint Secretary in the Department of Information Technology of a state. The government recently implemented several citizen-centric digital services, collecting large volumes of personal data from residents. The Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, requires that such data be processed only with explicit and informed consent, and mandates that processing must cease immediately upon withdrawal of consent. During an internal audit, you discover that the department continues to process and analyze personal data of several citizens even after they have formally withdrawn their consent. This data is being used for policy analytics and service improvement, purposes not explicitly disclosed at the time of data collection. When you bring this to the attention of your department head, you are informed that halting the processing will disrupt ongoing digital initiatives and may affect state-level performance metrics. Moreover, you find that the consent withdrawal process is cumbersome, and many citizens are unaware of their rights under the DPDP Act. You also learn that a prominent social activist is planning to file a complaint with the Data Protection Board against involuntary use of personal data, which could attract public scrutiny and legal action against the department. (a) Identify and discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) What are the potential consequences for the department if the issue is not addressed transparently? (c) How would you balance the need for efficient public service delivery with the obligation to protect citizens' data rights?
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
The given situation unravels disregard for citizen's consent and maintenance of 'form justice' over 'substantive integrity'.
"Legal frameworks in letter and spirit." - OECD framework to public service delivery.
(a) Ethical issues
Ethicality is the hallmark of Nolan Committee recommendations.
1. Rule of Law disobeyed as DPDP Act mandates consent 2. Lack of legal integrity among officials -> 'known disregard' of provisions 3. Ignorance and rationalised delinquence -> 'citizen disruption' of initiatives 4. Eventual loss of public trust - eg. Aadhar data leak case and subsequent problem 5. Government as protector & security provider -> surveillance state 6. Data privacy and misutilisation 7. Breach of social contract via 'undisputed utilisation of data' - eg. gerrymandering 8. Moral ambivalence due to broken checks and balances
(b) Potential consequences
1. Loss of public trust and disconnected 'publicness' 2. Increased vigilance among citizens -> political apathy and fatalism at their end 3. Breach of stakeholder confidentiality -> reduced stakeholder participation 4. Lax and 'chalta hai' attitude among officers under me -> leadership deficit -> chain of devilish action 5. Trivialisation of data privacy 6. Imposition of non-consensual working -> spillover to other domains & personal integrity loss 7. Reputational loss of DoIT & falling credibility of institution - 'Gilded Age' of Mark Twain
(c) Balance: public service delivery vs citizen's data right
Instil a sense of 'citizen centricity' (Kaushal Kishore case, 2024)
| Action | Rationale | |---|---| | Rejuggle erstwhile trends analysis | Innovative thinking; Constructive approach (Karmayogi mission); Leadership in triumphant times | | Report misuse of data & breach | Disclosure & transparency; Precedent setting; Leading by example | | Look for different ways of data-based governance | Newer survey be conducted; Diversified perspective; Objectivity maintained | | Integrity pacts signing | Law as first letter; Rule of Law; Value-based work culture instilled | | Conduct of new survey with longer validity | Objectivity preserved; holistic thinking; Deontological maintained |
'Moral earnestness' is first mark of productive governance (Santhanam committee)