Topper Copies

“A politics of confession that encourages politicians and parties to confess and offer regret for their errors can surely be a cathartic experience.” Examine the statement from the ethical point of view.

Rupal Jaiswal, AIR 43, 2025

Rousseau once remarked 'those who think of politics and ethics as separate fail to understand both'. Encouraging confessions from politicians is like infusion of ethicality in a frankenstein monster.

Can be a Cathartic experience

1. Politicians seen as exemplars ↓ Their mistakes publicity creates wrong social influence 2. Confession breaches secrecy required in political offices & oath of secrecy under Constitution 3. Politics is more about realism - Machiavellian ethics require practicality, not idealism

However, politics without principle is a Gandhian sin. Hence, ethical confessions and admission of errors desirable:

1. Ensures transparent decisions (eg) RTI to expose 2. Bring humanistic touch to politics ↓ to err is human, to forgive is divine 3. Combats corruptions for one will have to disclose data 4. Responsible exercise of power - checks orbitrary decisions (A V Dicey's Rule of Law ensured)

Thus, political confessions must be encouraged - Former PM Lal Bahadur Shastri resigned for a train accident - use him as role model