Topper Copies

The key to effective decentralization is, 'political decentralization should follow finance and functional decentralization'. Discuss in the context of impediments faced by local governance in India.

Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023

The local governance or third tier governance was recognized by 73rd & 74th CAA, 1992 and was empowered as per the vision of constitution in DPSP Art 40. but recent years has witnessed many issues in effective Decentralization:-

Challenges in Political Decentralization

1. caste based discrimination is legal Rational structure. 2. State election commission (Art 243K) lack effective resources & powers in conducting elections 3. Elections are not held regularly eg Tamilnadu ULB election held after 10 year

Financial Decentralization

4. less scope of fund raising 5. Dependent on state & central grants 6. 92% funds given are tied to schemes/works => No autonomy 7. Local government find it difficult to levy taxes in its own constituency 8. State finance commission (243I & 243Y) are not regularly set up 9. No serious consideration over recommendation of state finance commission.

Functional Powers

- State don't devolve effective powers to local tier - Constitution says "states may..." and thus leaving this crucial part on the discretion of state. - many important functions like drinking water, sanitation, education etc are not share with local govt.

Other issues

- "Sarpanch pati" shows proxy powers - failing the purpose of positive reservation. - Infrastructural gap - No computers & own quarters. - functionary -> lack of talent & skills.

What should be done?

Effective decentralization can happen through

1. Political Decentralization - Regularly establishing SEC and holding elections - Effective role of women & other caste people to maintain inclusivity. Eg 44.4% Representation of women highlighted by Global Gender Gap Index (WEF) 2. Financial Decentralization - Devolving powers to fund - Implement 15th FC recommendation of local government grants. - Institutional measures like formation of SFC (state finance commission) 3. Functional Devolution - Art 243 G (11th schedule, 29 subjects) - Art 243 W (12th schedule, 18 subjects) - All should be devolved for effective utilization of resources

The third tier government has key role in the democracy (2nd ARC) As it helps in better planning and Executing the schemes and thus ensure inclusive growth.