Topper Copies

'S.R. Bommai v. Union of India signified a paradigm shift in the judicial interpretation of the union's authority to assume control of a state's administration.' In this context discuss the significance and impact of the judgement on cementing the federal structure.

Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023

S.R. Bommai V/s U/o India 1994 laid many basic guidelines through which India's federal structure become more stronger.

Judicial interpretation & its impact

1. federalism was made a basic structure of the constitution.

Helped in Decentralization - Power Devolution importance - Ensuring grass root democracy

2. Democracy & Democratic principles were highlighted and was made a part of basic str. (Impact) - Democratic Decentralisation was emphasised. - More emphasis on devolution of power 3. Judiciary guided Union to sparingly use power of Emergency. - sparingly use Art 365 (President rule) to assume powers of state. (Impact) - made union conscious to use this power rarely. - Recognise state's autonomy and its role in resolving issue cooperatively. - Limiting role of Parliament and thus ensuring cooperative federalism. 4. Secularism was also made a part of Basic Structure. (Impact) - Strengthening and reasserting the state's impartial role in sphere of Religion. (Art 25 to 28) - Judiciary highlighted that "secular aspect of life shouldn't be mixed with Religion"

Thus S.R Bommai case helped in cementing the federalism, by highlighting the various provisions of constitution & basic structure