Analyze the ideological differences and similarities between the revolutionary movement(1920-1930s) and the Gandhian non-violent struggle. How did these two ideologies influence each other?
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
Gandhiji's article in Young India refered to "Cult of the Bomb", the rebuttal written by Bhagwati Charan Vohra "Philosophy of the Bomb", implying these two ideologies coexisted at time of struggle, vying for superiority.
Ideological differences between the two
| Gandhiji's | Revolutionary | |---|---| | 1. Means: peaceful, deontology | 1. Means: violent, Utilitarianism | | 2. Mass movement | 2. Emancipation through individual sacrifice | | 3. "Turning the other cheek" passivity | 3. "Striking first" activity | | 4. Death not acceptable outcome | 4. Death acceptable | | 5. Commitment defining of nationalism | 5. Sacrifice defining of nationalism |
Similarity between two
1. Indian freedom from British yoke 2. frustration with British attitudes 3. Socialism at forefront - HRSA by Bhagat Singh and Gandhian socialism of Nehru 4. Mutual support during difficulty - Gandhiji 11 demands included Commuting sentence of Bhagat Singh 5. Working as units - Gandhiji's congress Committee - HRSA by Azad ; Abinav Darpan by Savarkar.
How these ideologies influenced each other
A) Non Violence or Revolution
1. Bal Gangadhar Tilak started off as pacifist -> his death and Lala Lajpat Rai's death during Simon Go Back campaign lead to Revolutionary mechanisms 2. Virendranath Chattopadhyay (London) & Madam Cama (Paris) as pacifists secretly supported their actions 3. Poetic messaging : symbolism - Even before Salt Satyagraha in 1930, Bhagat Singh exploded a smoke bomb in LA to make the deaf hear.
B) Revolutionaries affecting Non violent struggle
- Tacit endorsement by Gandhi in (Quit India Movement) for violence adoption - mechanism of grievance airing became more Individual oriented - (eg) Individual Satyagraha to prevent mass harm
The two movements have sufficiently influenced each other while working towards larger goal of Independence