Fundamental rights are not gifts bestowed upon by the state rather an individual possesses them independently of the state. In this context discuss the desirability of reasonable restrictions on various fundamental rights.
Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023
Fundamental rights are basic human rights enshrined in the constitution under Part III. (Art 12-35).
Desirability of Reasonable Restriction
1. Fundamental Rights are not sacrosanct. 2. Ones fundamental Right can endanger others basic rights too eg Right to free speech & expression [Art 19(1)(a)] can lead to hate speech, Defamation, Contempt of court etc => Thus restrictions [19(2)] 3. Reasonable restriction keep check on individual's rights to maintain Rule of law eg Right to move freely (19(1)(d)) of a person can endanger cultural Rights (Art 29) of Tribals 4. To ensure Right to life & liberty (Art 21) Eg 'Right to privacy' can't be abridged by others as its basic essential part of human life & dignity. 5. Reasonable restrictions to protect public Order, sovereignty & integrity of nation. eg Art 19(2) 6. To prevent state from favouring any particular Religious group or institutions. 7. To ensure public interest at large eg. Not telling the grounds of preventive detention - Officials of Army, Navy etc are not allow to fully enjoy their freedom of speech & expression. 8. To maintain social harmony and the welfare of people at large. eg. - Religious propagation can be done but proselytizing can't or forceful conversion is not allowed. - freedom to work/profession (19(1)(g)) can't allow human trafficking.
However there are certain challenges like ambiguities in words, judicial activism etc but fundamental Rights provide as Bedrock of the constitution.