Critics assert that limitless judicial authority rests on the structural ambiguity of the basic structure doctrine. Has the elastic nature of the basic structure doctrine made the judiciary more powerful than the executive?
Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023
Basic structure doctrine brought by hon. SC in kesavananda Bharati case (1973) highlights that there are some core principles of the constitution which shouldn't be amended or changed.
Limited power of Parliament, Separation of power (Judiciary & Executive) and independence of judiciary are some elements of it. -> As separation of power is a basic structure limitless judiciary is against basic structure.
Basic structure doctrine - making Judiciary powerful
4. Basic structure doctrine is not codified. Neg- Neither its the part of constitution. - Its ever evolving process and the elements of it is said by judiciary which gives judiciary more power than executive.
Arguments Against
1. the basic structure doctrine and judicial autonomy has made the constitution a "living document" - Evolving as per need of the society eg. Limited power of Parliament, federal structure Free & fair elections etc. eg Expansion of fundamental Rights ( K.S Puttaswamy case Right to privacy ) 2. the independent judiciary actively takes part in the welfare of society. eg- Guidelines for sale of Acid in Laxmi case - Vishakha guidelines to prevent sexual harassment 3. Judiciary fills the vaccume created by inactive Executives eg Directing government to take step in manipur crises ASAP. 4. Basic structure doctrine also mentions separation of power as an element i.e It doesn't promote limitless judiciary rather an independent judiciary.
what should be done?
- A codification can be thought by learning from Germany. - Judiciary is also not exempted from check (Review) - Art 137 provides for Judicial Correctness (Review Petition)
Basic structure doctrine has been asserted by SC time & again and thus form the bed rock and a guiding light to the Constitution.