How has the Anti-Defection Law impacted the relationship between political parties and individual legislators in India? In light of the recent incidents also discuss the unintended consequences it has on the functioning of democracy in India.
Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023
Anti defection Law or the method of disqualifying a candidate based on defection was inserted into the constitution by 52nd constitutional Amendment Act 1985, in 10th schedule of the constitution.
How does it impact relation
1. Whip or the party head orders & regulates all the actions of an individual. 2. It has the provision that exempts merger if 2/3rd member of party wants to merge to another party. 3. However 91st CAA removed provision of split (1/3rd member earlier could split from the party) 4. strain in relations - Delay in decision and final Authority lies with speaker/chairman (who themselves are a member of any party).
Unintended consequence on Democracy
1. No Members are not allowed to listen to their own conscience -> only follow whip order 2. Exemption is based on number and not based on reason. i.e If wrong is done by majority, it won't be punished. 3. It doesn't allow to vent out dissent which ultimately gets form of disruptions and protests by MPs/MLAs in house. 4. As representatives are only following whip guidelines -> are often not able to exercise people's will thus undermine democracy. 5. Speaker is a member of party thus question impartiality and also doesn't have the judicial expertise
However there are some positive consequence
way forward
- Dinesh Goswami committee says that it should be used only when danger to government. - 2nd ARC says Authority should be with President/Governor on consultation with ECI.
Supreme court in Keisham meghchandram case & fixes 3month for decision.