Topper Copies

Compare and contrast the features of ancient Indian universities like Nalanda and Takshashila with modern state-funded universities in India. What lessons can modern universities learn from ancient ones to improve their effectiveness?

Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024

With Nalanda university open to all in its modern avatar, the ancient university breathes again.

| | Nalanda & Takshila | Modern State Funded Universities | |---|---|---| | 1 | Patronage: royalty / & rich donors. Huen Tsang records the revenue of 20 villages set-aside by Harsha for it alone | Patronage: occasionally govt (IIT/AIIMS) but more resources drawn from students through fees etc. | | 2 | Fees: Nominally to nil | Fees: Not affordable by all. (eg) IIT-Madras. per semester fee is 3 lakh rupees | | 3 | Merit based acceptance only | Merit based with affirmative action as well. | | 4 | Composition : mostly Indian teachers with foreign students (eg) Charakha, Sushrutha & Aryabhatta | Composed of largely Indian students only even in premier institute | | 5 | Liberalness & autonomy in functioning | Functioning under mandate of Min of Education - subject to dictates | | 6 | Place of openness to all forms of thought | Restricted dimensions of opinionation (eg) IISc Bangalore Students not permitted permission for vigil | | 7 | Mostly religious education received (eg) Itsing received Mahayana Buddhism | Secular education only - religious not permitted |

What modern institutes can learn from past

1. Self sufficiency /autonomy ; preventing state dictates on Curriculum to ensure education not bound by idea of ruling morality 2. Diffusion of ideas - learning from different cultures through student exchanges etc 3. Open to all-access Merit at forefront - Artificial barriers (eg money, passport requirements preventing intellectually curious from being selected over the financially wealthy 4. Fusion of multiple disciplines - eg Nalanda with music & science giving rise to science of music 5. Experimentation : academic liberty to drive change.

Much maybe integrated from past institutes but we must be mindful they flourished under different circumstances, therefore tailoring current demands to requirements is more apropos