Do you think the Uniform Civil Code contradicts the idea of religious pluralism and cultural differences in Indian society?
Rangamanju, AIR 24, 2024
Uniform Civil Code refers to homogenous legislative body made applicable to all religions in Marriage, Divorce, Inheritance, Adoption etc
UCC contradicts idea of pluralism
1. Religious minority rights specifically vested in Ar 29 / Ar 30 2. Right to religious expression. vested in Ar 25 - Ar 28 3. 'Homogenizing' a heterogenous agency forcefully 4. No space for unique circumstances / Local consideration - 'One Size Fits All Approach' 5. Enforces majoritarianism into secular setting 6. Issues with implementation and acceptance
UCC upholds ideas of pluralism
1. Prevents discrimination - ep Muslim women unfairly treated - Shah Bano case (1980) & Shayara Bano (Triple Talaq case) 2. Uniformity in secular code brings about integrity reducing sectarian movements 3. Protects women's right specially in property issues - Muslim women limited claim in coparcenery capacity 4. UCC ensures equality principle - Art 14 in letter and spirit
The 22nd Law Commission recommends UCC maybe adopted after necessary consultations with religious leaders to advance democratic credentials to the disempowered sections and allow national integration