The question of gender equality is central to the debate on Uniform Civil Code. In this light what are the challenges in reconciling UCC with gender equality as enshrined in the constitution?
Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023
UCC can be defined as the process of applying similar law across the India in matters of civil cases like marriage, Adoption, Divorce etc. instead of different personal laws.
Why it should be implemented:
1. Ensure Gender equality - Personal laws are disproportionately favouring men. (eg) Triple Talaq - Law can enhance gender equality (eg) Equal co-parcenary rights in inheritance. 2. Constitutional mandate - Art 44 directs State to implement UCC. 3. Supreme Court in case Shayra Bano Case highlighted its importance in National integrity & harmony. 4. Sarla Mudgal case -> SC said that its power of parliament to being UCC in effect.
Challenges
1. S.R. Bommai case 1994 - SC upheld that state being secular shouldn't interfere with personal laws. 2. Still a sensitive issues can being religious conflict & instability. 3. Civil laws are equal already (eg> contract Act, Evidence Act etc- 4. Jeopardising Tribal's rights (Art 29) (eg> Tribals distinct cultural rights and practices are at risk 5. Law Commission said that its neither necessary nor desirable.
Way forward
- A gradual Approach is needed (Piecemeal approach) - Codification of personal law can help in reducing arbitrariness.
In constituent assembly, B.R Ambedkar also supported UCC but advocated for its being voluntary and not forced.