Topper Copies

There is a need to resolve the ambiguity in the disqualification provisions under section 8 of the Representation of People Act 1951. Discuss.

Thakur Anjali Ajay, AIR 43, 2023

Representation of people Act 1951 provides various provisions like Qualification, Disqualifications, seats in parliament etc thus providing clear idea about the election process

section 8(4) was identified as unconstitutional by SC in Lily Thomas case (2013) which provided that MP can hold position/seat if appeals to SC within 3 months.

What are the ambiguities?

1. Election commission's discretion - MP can approach to ECI under Section 11 of RPA, 1951 - Discretion to remove disqualification 2. Ambiguous terms and not clearly defined. Eg Case of defamation could have been given a sentence of less than 2 year

However RPA, 1951 has also highlighted other clear grounds for disqualification which helps in strengthening democracy Eg - Corrupt practices (sec 123) - prevent promoting enmity, practicing untouchability or appealing to ascriptive identities.

Thus RPA, 1951 is an important act guiding towards achieving vision of free & fair elections.