Bring out the similarities and differences between detribalisation and pseudo-tribalism.
Mansi Singh, AIR 126, 2025
Tribalism is presence of tribal elments in group. Pseudo-tribalism is thus fake imitation of Tribal practices while detribalisation is returning to tribal practices.
Similarities ① Both lead to revival of tribal practices. ② Both aim for affirmative action as provided by government. ③ Both give up existing non-tribal practices ④ Both led to acculturation of Tribal way of life.
Differences
| | Detribalisation | Pseudotribalism | |---|---|---| | ① | The group originally was a tribe. | The group originally is a caste. | | ② | It was present even pre-independence phase. | It is a post-independent function | | ③ | Case Study: Surjit Shinha studied "Kshatriyisation" of Bhumij tribe. This is now again claiming tribal status. | Case Study: Caste around Gonds in Andhra started copying Gondi way of life and live in tribal hamlets left by Tribals. | | ④ | The main aim is revival of tribal culture along with reservation | The only aim is to get affirmative policies even by fake certificate |
Due to reservations in education and jobs, people are following Pseudo-tribalism and Detribalisation.