Examine the effect of job reservation on tribal unemployment. Discuss the issues with it in the light of the Xaxa Committee's recommendations.
Mansi Singh, AIR 126, 2025
As per NSSO report, 53% of tribal population is under employed while unemployment rate stands at 4.3% (women) and 3.4% (men) in rural area.
Effect of Job reservation in alleviating unemployment ① It created affirmative action for tribal to increase education level and thus decrease unemployment. ② It gives support in coming out of clutches of deprivation and discrimination. ③ As per B. D. Sharma, job reservation has reduced unemployment to certain extent. ④ In line of tribal panchsheel as tribals employed in administration
Issues with job reservations ① As per Chaudhary (1990), benefits are driven by few groups and led to emergence of 'TRIBAL ELITES' ② As per Asian institute of Anthropology studies, there is provision of 7.5% reservations, yet only 6.5% seats are filled. ③ As per reports, tribes have more representation in group C and D post while in A and B groups, representation is minimal. ④ Even now, literacy rate is just 59%, thus large population in outside of purview of reservation. ⑤ Discrimination: even in government services due to tribal way of life.
Recommendation of Xaxa Committee ① Strict adherence to 7.5% of reservation to fulfil seats. ② Provide alternate livelihood measures to improve employment. ③ Enhance education level to bring more STs in administration,
Tribal reservation is sine qua non for overall development of Tribal as per Dandekar Committee.