Topper Copies

Critically examine how post-independence forest laws have treated tribals, with reference to the National Forest Policies of 1952 and 1988 and the Forest Rights Act, 2006.

Mansi Singh, AIR 126, 2025

Tribes are called as "Janjati" meaning "caste living in forest" (i.e. Jan + Jati). Tribal life revolves around forest and thus forest laws play pivotal role in tribal development.

Post-Independence forest laws

A) Forest laws of 1952 This was first forest law after independence.

Features: - ban on shifting cultivation. - ban on digging wells, using forest resources. - Stringent forest bureaucracy - same forest as british policies -> Reserved forest, Protected forests.

Review - some claims that it was even stricter and more exploititive for tribal then British's forest Act of 1927.

B) Forest Policy of 1988 Correcting the loopholes of 1952 Act, tribals were provided more rights in this policy.

A) Joint Forest Management; for tribal way of life and conservation of forest. Eg Maldhari Tribe of Gujarat.

B) Sacred groves were recognised for tribals Nature-Man-spirit complex.

Review - provided "nature-led tribal life" -> 1st time recognised that tribes are actually "protector of forest"

C) Forest Right Act, 2006 First time, rights of tribals were recognised and comprehensive legislation was formulated.

Rights of tribal - Ownership ① Individual right: to collect forest produce upto 4 hectare (outer strip of tribal. ② Use Right: to use the forest produce as tribal livelihood eg right to collect MFPs. ③ Management of forest: with forest officials.

Issues with three laws A) Tribals awareness: As per MoTA, 19 lakhs claim under FRA have been declined without notifying tribal. Tribals are not aware of their right. B) Not in sync with Wildlife Protection Act, 1972. C) Displacement from forest areas

Case Study - 216 Saharia families displaced from Kuno Palpur tiger reserve due to relocation of cheetah. Similarly, Mankidia tribe was displaced from Achanakmar T.R.

Recommendation of Birsa Munda committee ① Signature of Gram Sabha before any eviction from forest land. ② Utilise CAMPA fund for tribal settlement in new forest area ③ Notify tribals with reason for disregard of claim of FRA.

Tribals are "Vanvasi" and effective development is needed for "Sustainable development".