Critically examine the post-independence approaches to tribal development in India: isolation, assimilation and integration.
Mansi Singh, AIR 126, 2025
A) Isolation Approach This was first given by Hutton which focuses on separation of tribes from mainstream.
It was supported by Verrier Elwin as method of tribal development in his book "The Baiga". He proposed 'National Park Theory' as mainstream is major factor of Tribal deprivation.
Criticism: A.V. Thakkar criticised that this isolation is important only for theoretical study by anthropologist as they will make Tribe as 'Living museum'.
B) Assimilation This was given by A.V. Thakkar and Ghurye.
According to them, there is no difference between caste and tribe. Tribal assimilation is even ideal for Tribal development.
Ghurye in book "The Schedule Tribe" (1949) mentioned that different policies for tribals will sow the seed of disintegration and affect Nation Building.
Criticism: L.P. Vidyarthi in "Tribal culture of India" stated that even when tribal were in contact, they have always maintained tribal culture.
C) Integration This was proposed by L.P. Vidyarthi, Majumdar for tribal development. They believe that no outer culture should be imposed on tribes and their culture should be maintained as per their Nature-Man-Spirit Complex.
Conclusion Pt Nehru has given Tribal Panchsheel in book "The Philosophy of NEFA" and accepted Integration approach for tribal development.