Discuss the impact of modern democratic institutions on the traditional tribal political system. Suggest a way forward.
Mansi Singh, AIR 126, 2025
Since ancient time, Indian tribes have political system in form of tribal organization, chiefdom and elder-authority. However, Modern Democratic Institutions have impacted Tribals immensely.
Background Britishers recognised tribal organization as different from mainstream and recognised in 1901 census and defined completely in 1931 census as wholly and partially excluded area.
Positive Benefits ① Factor of change-
These brought many changes like-
a) Cooperation between traditional and modern authority to boost development of tribal area.
Among Gonds - Modern Authority: welfare and development policies. Traditional Authority: marriage and territorial dispute.
b) Created awareness of right of tribals and provided Tribal front to fight for their right. eg. Dongria Konda, PVTG of Odisha fought against project of Vendante for mining and later halted project.
c) Economic Upliftment by recognising rights. for ex: Tribe of Maharashtra (Muria Gond) -> came together for bamboo cultivation and used it to profit oriented business.
d) Healthy Competition between modern and traditional authority led to fight for better development as seen in Apatani tribe of North-East India.
Negative Impact of Modern Democratic institution
A) Loss of traditional authority eg. Majhi of Santhal and Hos lost their relevance due to Modern PRI. Similarly [?] lost its relevance in Madhya Pradesh
B) Dislike and revolt by tribes eg Teli of Odisha denied the authority of PRI and even led to disruption of election,
C) New leadership: L.P. Vidyarthi in ("Tribal Culture of India") noted that new leadership is politically motivated and focus on self-interest
D) Interference of Dominant Caste: [?] Anderson studied clientalism in Maharashtra and found that Maratha caste leads to "dummy Candidate".
Way Forward A) Bhuria Committee recommended integration of both traditional and modern institution. B) Public Account Committee on Tribals mentioned that modern institutions should be introduced gradually to reduced tribal disruption. C) Elwin Ao Committee also mentioned that dispute resolution of traditional institutions should be introduced.
Thus, modern Democratic Institution would bring better change if it is in line of tribal Panchayat.