Topper Copies

6.c) Assess the significance of concepts given by Robert Redfield in study of Indian civilization. (15 marks)

Sushir Shrikrushna Shriram, AIR 155, 2023

Robert Redfield, in his 'folk culture' work, has talked about various concepts like: - Folk-urban continuum - Great tradition & little tradition

based on his work among the Mexican village of Yucatan province.

Significance in Indian context

I) Folk-urban continuum (i) This idea was used by L.P. Vidyarthi to give the concept of sacred complex, in the sacred complex of Hindu Gaya, he demonstrated how interaction between the sacred centre and pilgrims leads to spread of urban traditions among the folk.

(ii) Similarly, D.N. Saraswati and Mckim Marriott used this concept to show the interaction between various cultural traditions.

Because of the diverse variety of culture, there is always a continuum as a result of interaction.

II) Great & little tradition Robert Redfield gave "classified traditions" based on their origin, in a folk culture or urban culture. Mckim Marriott & Milton Singer used it to give the concept of universalisation & parochialisation. Marriott, in the Kishangarh study, called universalisation the continuance of little tradition into great tradition, eg. Saluno festival to [?].

*fig. interplay of LT & GT*

Parochialisation is promotion of great tradition into little tradition, eg. Goverdhan puja to Gobardhan puja.

Criticism 1. S.C. Dubey criticised the great & little tradition dichotomy, calling India has around 6 traditions 2. Yogendra Singh criticised the urban-folk continuum, calling it nothing but a diffusion process 3. Subjective nature of traditions was heavily criticised

However, the students of Robert Redfield, like L.P. Vidyarthi, gave good [?] to him in terms of applying his concepts in Indian civilisation.