Topper Copies

Q6. (a) Examine Nature-man – spirit complex as an ecological concept. How other anthropologists viewed the NMS complex different from L.P.Vidyarthi. (20 marks)

Sushir Shrikrushna Shriram, AIR 155, 2023

L.P. Vidyarthi, in his paper 'The Nature-Man-Spirit Complex' on a hill tribe of Rajmahal, gave the concept of the N-M-S complex.

Influence: major influence of his teacher Julian Steward on this concept.

Concept and cultural ecology: L.P. Vidyarthi stated that the Indian tribes have a primitive way of life that is embedded in their surrounding nature. - Ex. Maler study: primitive shifting cultivator tribe

L.P. Vidyarthi demonstrated how they live in a harmonious relationship with nature and how their life is impacted.

*fig. cultural ecology*

L.P. Vidyarthi himself studied the matter & noted their cultural ecology complex. As per him, their religious practices of benevolent & malevolent gods are to please nature so that they can get good produce in Khalli.

Case study: Dongaria Kondhs protested against the Vedanta project citing it disturbs their NMS complex in Niyamgiri hills.

L.P. Vidyarthi himself studied the Pahira industrial complex and noted how its complex study can help in development with happiness.

Significance: - Helps in action anthropology - Development with happiness, problem solving approach, eg. Kharagar protest against hill cutting - Helps in sustainable development, eg. Madhusing Sahoo study on Mankadia tribe of Simlipal

Other Anthropologists

1. Pradeep Singh: restudied the Maler tribe after 20 years, and found indifferent attitude of Maler towards challenge due to integration with modern economy (P.S. Mann) 2. B.S. Cohen: advocated N-M's work as a mechanism to study tribal nature nexus 3. B.K. Roy Burman: used this concept to solve tribal problems of the Chota Nagpur belt; he advocated habitat based livelihood in case of displacement 4. S.C. Roy: worked out tribal problems of the Chota Nagpur belt due to disturbed [?] complex as a result of mining

Professor Redfield viewed the [?] complex as a folk culture tradition and termed it little tradition.

To summarise, the [?] complex has a huge action oriented significance and is a tool to balance development with displacement, like the recent example of the Peomil-pachami coal development project of West Bengal.