8.c) Compare and contrast the functionalist approaches of Bronislaw Malinowski and A.R. Radcliffe-Brown. What were their key contributions and criticisms? (15 marks)
Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024
Biological Functionalism by Malinowski & Structural Functionalism by Radcliffe Brown are two functionalist approaches
| | Biological Functionalism | Structural Functionalism | |---|---|---| | Need | Organic, psychological impulses which need to be satisfied | As necessary to ensure maintenance of society | | Function | Satisfaction of above impulses through culturally approved method | Maintenance of social structure | | Social Institution | Exist to provide for primary, secondary, integrative needs | Exist for recurrence of social activity for social stability | | Influence | Frazer's Golden Bough | Durkheim idea of pre-social fact | | Example | Magic exists to ensure that anxiety is reduced | Religion exists to ensure that in social relations: |
Malinowski's key contributions were
1. Works: "Argonauts of Western Pacific", "Scientific Study of Culture" 2. Brought Participant Observation in anthropology. 3. Fieldwork in multiple Institutions amongst Trobrianders: Religion, Magic, Economy etc. 4. Brought Economic Anthropology as a field. eg Kula Ring Study 5. Raised need of anthropologists to learn local language. 6. "Theory of Needs" to understand culture
Criticisms
1. Gluckmann said his work is crude materialism 2. Annette Weiner => Didn't pay attention to study of power, gender dynamics. 3. Ignored role of colonialism in culture change 4. Ahistorical in nature. 5. Generalization of specific study
Key contributions of Brown
1. Works: "Structure & function in Primitive society", "Andaman Islanders" 2. Brought Durkheim idea of society into anthropology 3. 2 types of social structure
4. Descent Theory of Kinship & understanding of kinship terminology => explained how in simple societies with large no. of relatives it is used to ensure relations. 5. Kinship behaviour for social stability
Criticism of his work
1. Ahistoric/static 2. DM Lewis => Data manipulation is synchronic studies 3. Justifies social pathologies like caste 4. Overharmonious view of society with no conflict => Dipankar Gupta - show caste & change today and have "muddled hierarchies"
Both researchers enriched field of anthropology with their work.