7.c) The concept of cultural relativism and the ensuing debates surrounding it have sparked discussions within Anthropology. Comment. (15 marks)
Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025
As per Rupert Redfield, cultural relativism refers to objectively analysing a society in the context of their society's problems and opportunities. It is a hallmark of Anthropology.
Origin of Concept
- Alain Locke coined the term in 1924 - In response to Classical evolutionism's ethnocentric approach, Franz Boas gave the concept of Historical particularism, saying that "each culture is meaningful in its own context" - The idea was further popularised by Eunice [?] and for Modernists
Benefits of Cultural Relativism
- Tolerant approach, for better understanding, eg: D.N Majumdar understood cultural reasons behind group marriage of Khasas sect - With suspicion all around the world, both myths, eg: Racism, [?] savage, hence tribes - Applied and Action Anthropology, eg: Rural perspectives enable Rapid Rural Appraisal; eg: Community Development Program by SC Dube - Ensuring world peace by removing xenophobia, eg: Nazi violence against Jews in WWII
However, cultural relativism has raised following fears.
Critics
1. Elizabeth Zechenter - It leads to violation of human rights in the name of cultural practice, eg: Genital mutilation in Akan of Ghana, [?] 2. Gender - Social approval should not precede moral approval, eg: Sati, child marriage, violate women's dignity and right to life 3. Maryam Namazie - It is used as excuse to justify practices like [?], males cliff-hanging practices of licking hot iron axe, houses falling in caste system
Herskovitz - "All judgements are based on past experience", raised the debate that being truly objective and unbiased is not possible with human psyche.
However, Paul Rosenblatt has correctly said that understanding the cultures with cultural relativism, and further convincing Indian tribes using the same understanding, is made possible by this approach.
Contemporary Relevance - And amid all these debates, there have been times when anthropologists used the understanding to solve vaccine hesitancy, and convince tribals for very important strategic decisions [?] forests. Used in the correct way, it can be used to solve problems as complex as left wing extremism.