Q8. (a) Describe the problems of Universal definition of marriage. (15 marks)
Manan Bhat, AIR 88, 2023
As per Herskovits ; Marriage is the union between a Man & a women. & children born to them are legi-timate offspring's of Couple.
Problem with such definition :-
1) union between a man & a women:- - Female - Female Nayar marriage's - Ghost marriage's; Polygamy/Polygyny. - Sologamy marriage (Gujarat Case). - Recent marriage of Mexican Mayor Victor Hugo with an alligator (2022) - Bantu People marrying with a Cattle. - Male-Male marriages (Gay relations)
2) legitimacy of the offspring's :- - legitimacy to child should be social approval; not legal one- e.g In Kikuyu Tribe of Africa, a women needs to have Kid with husband's relative for legitimacy to their own kids.
3) Definition of legitimacy by Malinowski :- Marriage is a relation such that women gets socially approved husband and children get socially approved father - Such definition only defines what is legitimate but falls short of defining nature of marriage
4) Kathleen Gough after studying Nayars of Kerala gave following definition:- Marriage is a union between a women and one or more individuals such that the children born to women ; not prohibited by rules of relationship are given full birth rights available to other individuals of the society
Exceptions :- - Bantu people marrying Cattle. - Male - Male marriages; - Sologamy.
Hence, from the above discussion's we can conclude that although marriage is a universal institution ; but universal definition of marriage is not possible due to varying needs in different societies from the institution of marriage.