Topper Copies

(b) Culture is unique to human beings. Do you agree? Present arguments in favour and against the statement. (15 marks)

Manan Bhat, AIR 88, 2023

E.B. Tylor in his book "Primitive Culture" 1861 has defined Culture as a complex whole of Knowledge, Art, Belief's, morals, Custom's law's and any other Capacity acquired by men as being part of society.

2 important aspects from above definition are:- - Culture is acquired by humans as part of society. - Culture is transmitted from one generation to other.

Is culture unique to human's ?

Arguments against this Statement :- 1) Gestural Communication observed in Chimpanzees - Jane Godall study. 2) Potato washing by monkey's (Kabwe). 3) use of tools for food gathering e.g Twig's & Stick's. 4) Kyoto University project where in Primates learned playing computer games and transmitted to peers.

Also, Kroeber's study of ants and wasp's also reflects the presence of proto-culture among these organisms.

Arguments for this statement :-

Although we can see that some sort of societal arrangement among primates but still they are not cultured being's :- - Their activity is hereditary & Instinctive. - They cannot bring about cultural transformation since only human's can pool there cognition & bring cultural changes. - Most activities are individualistic in nature. - Moreover, all these experiments were carried under lab conditions.

from above, we can conclude "culture is unique to human being's" for their peaceful survival and social stability