Topper Copies

Q.8) (a) Explain Tech-determinism approach of Leslie White in Anthropology. Also explain how Sahlins and service reconciled the debate between White and Steward. (20 marks)

Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024

Leslie White was an American anthropologist from Neo-Evolutionist school of anthropology.

Works

- Science of Culture. - Evolution of culture.

Tech-determinism approach of Leslie White

1. Evolution of a culture followed unilinear pattern of evolution => Savagery -> Barbarism -> Civilisation. 2. This pattern of change was based on type of energy harnessed in each stage - Savagery -> Human Muscle energy (eg) Hunting. - Barbarism -> Use of animal and plant energy (eg) Agriculture. - Civilisation -> use of new energy forms (eg) Machine energy like steam 3. Based on tech-determinism, he said the Social and Ideological aspects get affected. When technology changes, other aspect adapt to the change.

Steward criticized White for being generalized.

Later Julian Steward brought Cultural Ecology approach which proposed multi linear cultural evolution and idea that tech-environment determines culture more. White criticized for confusing history and evolution.

4. The type of energy harnessed is divided based upon the quality and quantity of energy harnessed 5. Both above parameters depend upon efficiency of harnessing energy. Technology employed determines 6. Based on this, he gave his idea that technology determines cultural change, tech-determinism of culture. 7. Law of culture change => ExT=C - E = Energy harnessed (total) - T = Technology which determines efficiency. - C = Cultural development

Ex

| Energy | Tech. | Culture | Example | |---|---|---|---| | Low | Low | Low | Inuits | | High | Low | Low | Africa | | High | High | High | western nations |

The above debate was reconciled by Sahlins (student of Steward) and Service (White's student) through idea of General and Specific Evolution of Culture

1. Evolution has dual character as per them 2. First it moves stage by stage in a nonlinear fashion from lower to higher forms. 3. There can be slipping of stages -> This is General Evolution

4. At the same time evolution can happen with diversity with each culture taking different adaptations for evolving => This is specific evolution

They merged both White and Steward's idea showing that cultural evolution is possible in multiple ways