7.c) Explain Cultural materialism school of thought in Anthropology. (15 marks)
Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024
Marvin Harris' In his work "cultural Materialism: A struggle for science of culture" brought out the cultural materialism theory.
Cultural materialism is the study of real, objective/materialistic reasons behind human action in all spheres.
Social structure is made up of 3 levels
1. Infrastructure = Mode of production & mode of reproduction. 2. Structure = Organisational level. (eg.) Political, economic system. 3. Super-structure = Ideological level (Eg.) religion, taboos etc.
As per cultural materialism, all are functionally interrelated
The Infrastructure determines the structure and super-structure. Structure, super-structure exist to maximise the Infrastructure.
Case Study -> Marvin Harris studied Minhas villas in Brazil. Post gold rush, the Infrastructure changed from farming to selling of goods and services to gold miners. This led to change in structure as economy was integrated in global money economy. The super-structure changed with establishment of Urban Ethos
Others important studies
- Patterns of Race & Racism was super-structure in America, to ensure more profits at infrastructure level as cheap labor. - Sacred Cow Complex => Importance of Cow in India as provides milk, ghee, protein source, curd, and oxen for farming.
Significance
1. Brought a scientific methodology. 2. Idea of cross-cultural comparisons 3. Inspired Chicago School studies in urban Anthro.
Criticisms
1. Structuralists => Emic thoughts ignored an individual role 2. Marxists => Super-structure only for capitalists & vulgar materialism 3. Post modernists against scientific method 4. Rappaport: Religion as super-structure affects infrastructure
While a simplified view, Harris helped in understand crisis of racism to the world.