Topper Copies

7.b) Discuss Lewis Henry Morgan's evolutionary framework in anthropology. How did his theories reflect Western biases and assumptions about cultural superiority and progress? (15 marks)

Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024

Lewis Henry Morgan was an American Anthropologist famous for his work "League of the Iroquois" & "System of Consanguinity and Affinity in Human Family".

Evolutionary framework proposed

- He based his work on EB Tylor's 3 stage evolution for society - He further sub-divided these into Upper, Middle and Lower individually, based on material culture.

Savagery (Hunting and Gathering) - Upper: Bow, arrow - Middle: Fire - Lower: Fruits, nuts - Eg. Australia, Polynesia

Barbarism (Agriculture) - Upper: Iron - Middle: Irrigation - Lower: Pottery - Eg. Iroquois

Civilization: Phonetics, alphabets, machine power - Eg. Victorian England

He further applied these evolutionary frameworks to different social institutions to explain their progress

- Political societies -> Civitas Gentes (lineage) -> Phratry (Clan) -> Tribes -> Nation (State) - Kinship: Kinship system were studied by him based on kinship terminology. classificatory -> descriptive - Based on these terminology, he explained the cultures moved from classificatory to descriptive eg Hawaiian -> Inuit -> Iroquois, Sudanese <- Crow <- Omaha - Marriage and Family => He described their evolution in 5 stages Consanguine -> Punaluan -> Syndasmian -> Patriarchal -> Monogamian

Theories by Morgan reflected Western bias & superiority

1. Western Idea of unilinear evolution 2. Colonial view of stratification of culture with Civilization at top. 3. Idea of monogamous as highest marriage form shown western view of marriage. 4. A L Kroeber: Kinship terminology are means of psychological expression => cannot be used to show how one culture is above another. 5. David Graeber in "Dawn of Everything" -> Against deterministic view of evolution - eg. Poverty point culture of Louisiana, Did pottery & long-distance trade without agriculture

In conclusion, Morgan's theory of change stands challenged. However he left indelible mark on anthropology.