5.a) Etic vs Emic Approach in Anthropological Research
Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024
Etic v/s Emic approach in anthropology has been a constant debate since the beginning of field as a academic discipline.
| | Etic | Emic | |---|---|---| | Proponents | Marvin Harris, EB Tylor | Franz Boas, Clifford Geertz | | Nature | Collection of quantifiable data; Objective and unbiased interpretation | Qualitative data collection; Subjectivist interpretation of findings | | Laws | Formulation of universal laws; Generalization of findings | No universal laws can be formed; Findings may or may not be generalized | | Methods | Use of sampling, statistical methods for data collection; Deduction is used | Use interviews, participant observation; Induction is used | | Variables | Variables used are those which are unique, distinct (eg. Leslie White used energy efficiency to evaluate culture change) | Variables are social and hard to quantify (eg. Geertz used 'thick description' to show power dynamics at play between various groups) | | Applied in | Used for applied biological anthropology | Used for socio-cultural anthropology |
Both etic and emic approach complement each other to make anthropological research holistic