5.b) Big Man based society and Chiefdom
Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025
Big Man based society and Chiefdom are types of political organisation. Political organisation, as per John Beattie, is the organisation to maintain orderly social relation in a defined/undefined territory between social groups.
As per Elman Service:
Big Man of Melanesia has charismatic leadership same as Chiefdom (often). Big Man often cares less about welfare of society and more about personal gain, and the same has been observed in chiefdom often.
Differences
1. Authority - Big Man - decentralised, not true authority; Chiefdom - true centralised authority 2. Territory there in chiefdom, unlike Big Man 3. Inheritance of authority is hereditary in Chiefdom, unlike Big Man. Big Man may rise or fall depending on his acts. He has a loyal fanbase which might die down soon 4. Chiefdom has complex political structure for maintaining social order unlike Big Man, for dispute resolution
Big Man, if influential enough with permanent following, might centralise the tribe to establish authority of his own in a permanent sense, but still Chiefdom is much higher in complexity.