Q.3) (a) Discuss Victor Turner's concept of liminality and communitas in the context of religious rituals. (20 marks)
Vaibhav Kumar, AIR 90, 2024
Victor Turner was an anthropologist from symbolic school of Anthropology.
Works - "The Forest of Symbols" - Schism and Continuity in an African Society.
Basic Premise and Influence
1. He was influenced by Emile Durkheim's idea of social solidarity 2. Social solidarity is a function of symbols which connect people. 3. Turner said symbols are primary instruments in achieving social solidarity. 4. Rituals are symbols which play central role in maintaining social order
Concept of liminality
1. Every ritual is aided by rites of passage with 3 primary stages.
Liminality is characterized as
- anti-structure phase. - loss of previous status - Haven't achieved new statuses - Symbolized by ambiguity
eg. Upanayan ceremony is rite of passage and liminal phase between childhood and joining school of learning.
1. Communitas is formed by all those who undergo liminal phase together. 2. It results in formation of intense solidarity. 3. Communitas can be of 3 types 1. Spontaneous communitas. Due to sudden change, those undergoing have solidarity 2. Ideological communities. Amongst those who have similar beliefs, valued etc. 3. Normative communities. Rules, norms bound the communities. This is point where schism begins and new liminal phase happens to ensure social solidarity. Schism happens as norms end up stagnating the structure.
Eg. Study of Ndembu Society and Puberty rituals
- During puberty rituals, girls are wound up blanket and put under Mudyi tree - Mudyi tree symbolizes a mother through its white latex secretion similar to mother's milk - It shows liminality as it signifies change in role for girls. - They are no more girls during the ritual - However, they haven't achieved status of woman. - Liminality as child is supposed to swallow instruction from mother and learn rights, duties of woman first. - Communitas is formed amongst girls who undergo together similar time of beginning of menarche. - Support for preparing for marriage and motherhood.
Criticism of liminality and communitas
1. Overly positive interpretation by Turner - eg. liminal phase of economic struggles Nazism emerged as communitas (Handelman) 2. Ignores power dynamics at play during rituals. - eg. Erode/Sallnow => Christian pilgrimages aren't liminal in shedding past social status -> Rather reinforces social hierarchy as difference in pilgrimage method
Turner enriched our understanding of society with his studies