4.b) Briefly explain Formalism and Substantivism Debate in Anthropology. How does the debate inform our understanding of contemporary economic issues such as globalization, poverty, and environmental sustainability? (20 marks)
Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025
As per Beals and Hoijer, Economic Anthropology studies production, distribution, exchange and consumption systems as they are interlinked in simple and modern societies.
Economic Anthropology is further subdivided into two major schools: Formalists and Substantivists, with their separate approaches for it.
Origin of debate
Karl Polanyi, via "The Great Transformation (1944)", introduced the substantivist revolution. He borrowed the debate from Max Weber's concept of formal rationality and substantivist rationality in Sociology.
Debate between both
| | Formalist | Substantivist | |---|---|---| | Scholars | Raymond Firth, M. Herskovitz, Sahlins | Polanyi, M. Sahlins, Dalton | | View | Societies should be studied with neoclassic economics using principle of demand and supply, profit and loss, rationality, money and trade, whether they are modern economies or simple societies | Simple societies' economies are based on kinship and thus all these principles fail to explain several practices among them, eg Kp's Indians don't till hills despite land scarcity as their ancestors used there | | Nature | Society is disembedded from economics | Economy of Simple Societies is embedded in their social norms - Karl Polanyi |
[two circular diagrams: one circle divided into "Society" above and "Economy" below, illustrating disembeddedness; two concentric circles with an arrow to the outer circle labelled "Society" and an arrow to the inner circle labelled "Economy", illustrating embeddedness]
Famous explanations by Sahlins in the following verses: - "Money is to the west, what kinship is to the east" - "Tribes are oppressives and non-maximisers"
He could very well explain the following practices:
However, several new realities like globalisation, poverty and environmental sustainability have changed the scenario: - Introduction of money and modern interests in tribal economy, eg. goods selling and hand made products digitally via e-commerce - Cultural impact, eg. alcohol and drugs introduced in tribal hamlets, most of them addicted - Global companies encroaching forest land leading to detribalised movements ([?] Srivastav) -> landless labor & fire kiln workers, eg. Sahariyas of Rajasthan, monkey catchers - Climate change -> increased vulnerabilities, Gaddi tribe losing pastures to carry on their economic activities
Hence, older simple kinship based economies running on generalised reciprocities have now been introduced to the modernised economic principles as listed in beginning.
Thus Plattner says that any one approach, either Substantivist or Formalist, can't explain this complex transition. Prattis says even modern economies have foundations without profit motive.
Thus both approaches should be used judiciously to understand contemporary economic issues.