(7-b) The study of Basic Personality allows us to explore the deep-seated psychological motivations and conflicts that underlie cultural phenomena. Discuss in view of Abraham Kardiner's Idea of Culture Personality School. (15 marks)
G Sahi Darsini, AIR 112, 2023
Abraham Kardiner, a proponent of culture personality school has propounded that there is a mutual influence of culture and personality on with each other.
He along with Ralph Linton in his book "Psychological Frontiers of Society" presented the idea of Basic Personality which he identifies as the common characteristics, attitudes & beliefs shaped by people of a culture owing to their common socialisation practices.
He gives a psychodynamic approach to culture change where in he divides cultural institutions into primary & secondary and opines that the primary institutions tend to shape basic personality of an individual which eventually affects the secondary institution.
He validates his theory through fieldwork among Marquesas.
| 1° institution | Basic personality | 2° institution | |---|---|---| | food shortage | conflictuous | Vebonitti: vicious | | polygamy | maternal neglect => unstable | women and seducers who kill eventually |
Social change among Tanala community:
- Need to inherit land from father → father son bond → ancestors as benevolent spirits - Economy change to wet rice cultivation → no longer need to inherit land → father son hostility → ancestors as malevolent spirits
Criticism:
1. The existence of multiple personalities & hence couldn't explain cultural variation 2. Not based on empirical facts 3. Over generalisations 4. Not applicable to modern societies which witnessed multiple migration.
Relevance:
1. The concept of basic personality used in National character Studies, 2. Diplomacy b/w nations 3. For market study in MNCs to understand consumer behaviour.
In summary, Kardiner's proposition of culture & personality mutually influence each other is widely accepted & he is credited for his interdisciplinary approach.