Q4. (a) How is the construction of power linked to the notion of conspicuous consumption and its impact on distributive justice. (15 marks)
Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025
Power as defined by Max Weber is the ability to take independent decision even in the face of resistance.
Power when legitimised is Authority, as per Robert A Dahl.
Power plays an important role in economic, political sphere as:
Case 1: Potlatch, by Kwakiutl (studied by Franz Boas) - those who hold power conduct potlatch ceremony where they destroy valuables, to raise status. This is accompanied by feasting which is a form of redistribution leading to distributive justice.
Case 2: Purpose of [?] - Chief/King who holds political power collects taxes from individuals and keeps a share of it for his conspicuous/luxurious consumption. Rest is redistributed to the society to ensure distribution justice.
=> Conspicuous consumption actually hampered distribution justice.
In above example, luxurious consumption by king actually leads to unfair usage of taxpayer's money, and though it seems that the remaining wealth is equally distributed to achieve justice, true distributive justice is not achieved here.
Thus, power actually can lead to decisions as per the will of power holders, and if not exercised properly can actually hamper true justice.
Contemporary Relevance
Same holds true for corrupt polity leaders of today's democratic polity.
"Power corrupts" and "Absolute Power corrupts Absolutely" holds true for every society, and can hence be dealt by limiting this power by authority.