Topper Copies

2.c) Discuss the nature of Law and Justice in simple societies citing suitable examples. (15 marks)

Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025

Law as per Hoebel refers to use of force to punish those who deviate from established customs and to regulate the behaviour of individuals.

It is an element of the broader justice system that involves the process of dispute resolution and establishing societal peace.

Law in Simple Society

- As per Radcliffe Brown, simple societies don't have law, they just have social sanctions to react to desirable or undesirable situations - However as per Hoebel and Lowie Hoerland, totality of these sanctions applied during breach of these established customs actually form primitive/customary law

Characteristic of law

Primitive laws are: - Developed gradually and organically - Based on customs, societal values, parables and narratives - Do not differentiate between private and public wrong - Only criminal and no civil law - No uniform code of punishment - Believe in concept of supernatural and sin - No full time enforcing agencies - Collective responsibility of kin

These laws are insufficient/against human rights and are unjust, however, they need...

Justice in Simple Societies

It involves several procedures like:

1. Establishing Evidences via - Oath - promise in the name of important objects, eg. Santhals - "Dharam Dharam"; the oath of Bhagvadgita in today's times is also derived from these - Ordeal - tough situation which needs a miracle by supernatural, eg: Madu-Saweli - lucky for axe - Domination by supernatural, eg: Punish shaman - Extension, eg. USA tribes can curse witch to find out truth from them 2. Punishment - Via village council, eg: Santhal council ask to pay by "feast" if incest done - Fine or compensation, eg: Kamars of MP pay hefty fines for adultery 3. Dispute resolution

Simple societies thus follow simple systems, without specific specialists. Justice there is enforced by kin, and as nobody can escape his [?], their priority is social harmony, so social order is better maintained in simple societies.