Topper Copies

Write the differences between the Ethnocentrism vis-à-vis Cultural relativism with the suitable examples?

Nidhi Pai

Ethnocentrism is a phenomenon when one's own social group is considered superior and others are judged or scaled in reference to our own social group. (Ex) - USA - consumption of dog meat is barbaric.

Cultural Relativism, as given by Franz Boas, deals with understanding cultures with respect to one's own history and environment and not based on our own culture. (Ex) Consumption of any meat taken equally without judging.

| Ethnocentrism | Cultural Relativism | |---|---| | Based on the concept of ingroups and outgroups given by W.G. Sumner. | Given by Franz Boas who also gave the concept of Historical Particularism. | | Brings Subjectivity in studies. | Brings Objectivity in studies. | | Close minded. | Open minded. | | Leads to discrimination. (Ex) - Racism. | Ensures social unity and peace. (Ex) - Secularism. | | Should be avoided by Ethnographers and Anthropologists. | Should be encouraged in researches. | | Has a history of large scale violence and wars. (Ex) - Nazism by Hitler in Germany. | Is known to promote tolerance and acceptance. (Ex) Mahatma Gandhi towards Harijans. |

Cultural Relativism is an anti-thesis to Ethnocentrism. They both lie on the polar ends of a spectrum. (Ex) - Franz Boas recommended learning the local language, living with the locals etc to study cultures. This will avoid Ethnocentrism and promote Cultural Relativism.

Later anthropologists took the concept of Cultural Relativism seriously in their studies to bring in objectivity. (Ex) - Margaret Mead, Coradu Bois, Malinowski etc.

Thus, it can be said that though both the concepts lie on the polar ends of a spectrum, they are completely opposite and different to each other.