Patriotism encourages ethical questioning, while nationalism often suppresses it. Discuss this statement in light of the formation of political attitudes during high-pressure national events. How can individuals develop moral attitudes that balance national interest with ethical reasoning?
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Patriotism refers to love for one's nation while Nationalism refers to feeling of one's country being better than others, a form of relative superiority.
Political attitudes in high pressure events
1. Nationalism dilutes tolerance - eg. Riots based on communal disharmony during India-Pakistan matches 2. Nationalism translates to chauvinism leading to irrational attitudes of supremacy -> Reduced sense of humanity by Nazi Germany during Lebensraum 3. Clarity of thought lost in face of emotive bombing - eg. 'empathetic numbing' of ceasefire; ill comments on foreign secretary 4. Rising 'mob mentality' pivots reactive actions without balance of moral attitudes - eg. US election debates
Balance of national & Ethical interest reasoning
1. Patriotic fervour sticks to love for country, not hate for others 2. 'Court of conscience' as main compass 3. Constitutional morality in action 4. Vivekananda's triumvate man
5. Rational basis to decipher ill-will for others - avoid nihilistic attitudes
Thus, patriotism is key (Article 51(A)(g)) but a balance of universal moral Kantian law and Gandhian ahimsa in cognitive, behaviour is important.