Topper Copies

Q4. (a) Mead's major contribution to anthropological theory was her demonstration of the importance of cultural rather than biological conditioning. Elaborate with relevant examples and case studies. (20 marks)

G Sahi Darsini, AIR 112, 2023

Margaret Mead belongs to the culture personality school of thought which tends to understand the relation between culture & personality in an anthropo-psychological approach.

She postulates against the then popular concept of biological determinism and instead proposed that Culture affects Personality (i.e Cultural determinism).

Major works

1. "Coming of Age in Samoa": She shows how adolescent in Samoa are more peaceful & rebellions than & engage in sexual relations more freely as compared to American adolescents who rather have a conflicting moral bound, more rebellions adolescence. This she says is due to enculturation practices in Samoa which discusses matters of age, sex etc at early age. 2. "Sex and Temperament in Three Primitive societies": She shows how in three societies living in close proximity to each other there is a difference in gender roles owing to culture difference.

| | Arapesh | Mundugumor | Tchambuli | |---|---|---|---| | Cause | live in isolated place free from enemy attack | constant threat & hence compulsive fear etc. | more involvement of female in economy | | Effect | men & women both submissive | Men & women both aggressive | henpecked men, aggressive women |

Thus she says personalities of men & women are shaped by their cultures. 3. "And Keep Your Powder Dry": National Character Study among Japanese, Chin, Russians & Americans whose children were the same personalities when infants but later as enculturation affects them is difference in personalities which occurs.

The nature, acting over nurture (genes) (culture) 4. She also writes on how cultural restrictions have shaped personalities of women to be subordinate and hence actively worked in feminist movements.

Positivist Methodology

1. Visual & photographic methods 2. Content analysis method 3. EMIC view of study

Criticism:

1. Naomi Harris; criticises her emic mode of study (lack of holism) & also sampling errors; Mead Samoan study has only adolescent girls & no one to validate. 2. Derek Freeman accuses her of fabricating the data in order to prove a pre-conceived theory. 3. Crisis of representation critique: samples too small to represent whole population. 4. Over generalistic and unrealistic.

Relevance:

1. Can help establish against the social discriminations 2. Culture conditioning & enculturation practices are now given even more importance with specialized institutions emerging for it. 3. These thoughts became the basis of feminist school of anthropology.

Thus Margaret Mead has been one of the most influential anthropologist whose works raised scholarly debate & also attracted popular support with equal vigor.