Topper Copies

Q2. (a) What are the defining characteristics of a scientific discipline, and does Anthropology meet those criteria? (15 marks)

Sania Seervi, AIR 450, 2025

As per Vaid, Oriental Anthropology (2021), Anthropology is the holistic study of socio-cultural and biological evolution and variation in a human across space and time.

It is an important discipline with its roots in many social sciences like Sociology, Psychology, History, Economics, Political Science, as well as scientific disciplines like Geology, Earth Science, Life Sciences (Biology, Zoology, Anatomy) and Medical Sciences.

Characteristics of a scientific discipline

- Based on rational logic and not any superstition or subjective beliefs - Objective analysis of phenomena - Establishment of cause and effect relationship - Devising universal laws and formulae based on observation and hypothesis - Testing the laws and applying them in a real life situation for deriving utility for mankind and world

Anthropology similar to scientific features

- Using emic approaches, several anthropologists have analysed phenomena objectively - Eg. Cultural materialists have analysed Potlatch ceremony of Kwakiutl as a safety valve for malnutrition - Cause and effect relationships have been established - Eg. Alliance theory states that alliances via marriages have the reason of preventing wars - Eg. Biocultural adaptations to extreme climate like the [?] gene in Tibetans - Universal laws - Eg. Development of larynx bone led to voice development - Eg. Erect posture of man led to narrowing of birth canal and hence led to need of social bonding and family

However: - Emic approach leads to subjective interpretation of phenomena each time, eg. Historical Particularity - Diverse cultural practices have subjective reasons with varying cultural constructs, making it difficult to generalise universal laws - Eg. Edmund Leach says even though Kathleen Gough's definition of marriage is wider, it is not universal

Thus, anthropology's beauty lies in its diversity and not scientific generalisation.